The Buyer Who Wants To Put 20 Percent Down and Wait Until They Have It - soravel
Back to blog
Buyer Representation

The Buyer Who Wants To Put 20 Percent Down and Wait Until They Have It

I had a buyer call me last spring who had been saving for three years. Disciplined. Focused. The kind of client you want to work with. And she told me she was not ready to buy yet because she only had 14 percent saved and she was going to wait until she hit 20. I asked her how long that would take. She said maybe eight more months. I said, can I show you something real quick? She said sure. That conversation changed everything - not because I was trying to close her, but because nobody had ever sat down with her and done the actual math out loud.

This is one of the most common situations I see agents completely fumble. The buyer is not being difficult. They are not wasting your time. They have been told their whole life that 20 percent down is the responsible thing to do, and they are trying to do the responsible thing. Your job is not to talk them out of being responsible. Your job is to show them what responsible actually looks like in the real numbers of their specific market right now.

What the 20 Percent Myth Is Actually Costing Them

Here is where most agents make their first mistake. They hear '20 percent' and they launch into a speech about loan products. FHA this, conventional that, PMI is not that bad. And the buyer's eyes glaze over because now they feel like they are being sold something. Stop doing that. Instead, start with the asset side of the equation.

Ask them what homes in their target range are priced at right now. Then ask them what those same homes were priced at 18 months ago. If your market has moved even 4 to 6 percent annually - which is conservative in most markets we are tracking heading into 2027 - the house they want today is going to cost them more in eight months than the PMI they are trying to avoid will ever cost them over the life of the loan. That is not a sales pitch. That is arithmetic. And when you frame it that way, you are not selling them on buying - you are helping them understand what waiting is actually worth in dollars.

The other number that never gets surfaced in this conversation is the rent they are paying while they save. I had my buyer pull up her lease. She was paying $1,850 a month. Eight more months of waiting meant $14,800 more in rent paid to someone else while she was trying to get to a threshold that might not even benefit her the way she thought it would.

The PMI Conversation Nobody Has Correctly

PMI has the worst reputation in real estate and most of it is earned from bad explanations. When an agent says 'PMI is not that bad,' the buyer hears 'I am minimizing your concern to get you to sign something.' That is not a trust-building moment.

Here is how I actually have this conversation. I say - 'PMI exists for one reason. It protects the lender if you default. That is it. What it costs you depends entirely on your credit score, your loan amount, and your lender. For most buyers in your situation, we are talking somewhere in the range of $80 to $200 a month on a loan this size. And the moment you hit 20 percent equity in the home - whether that is from your payments, the market appreciating, or both - you request to have it removed and it is gone. So the real question is not whether PMI is bad. The question is whether paying PMI for two or three years costs you more than waiting eight months and buying a more expensive house without it.'

Then you stop talking. Let them do the math in their head. That silence is not awkward. That silence is them thinking. And agents who are afraid of silence kill deals that were about to close themselves.

How To Actually Run the Numbers in the Room

You need to be able to do this in front of them, not at home the night before and then recite it. When you do it live, with their numbers, it lands completely differently. Pull out a piece of paper or a notes app - I do not care what you use - and do three columns.

Column one: buy now with 14 percent down. What is the monthly payment including PMI. What is the purchase price today. Column two: buy in eight months with 20 percent down. Estimate a 4 percent appreciation on the purchase price. Recalculate the down payment they now need because the price moved. Add up the rent paid in those eight months. Column three: the difference. That number in column three is the actual cost of waiting. Not an estimated cost. Not a philosophical argument about the market. A specific dollar figure with their specific numbers.

When my buyer saw that the market moving 4 percent meant she needed to save an additional $12,000 on top of what she was already saving just to keep pace with the price increase - before she even touched the down payment threshold - she looked at me and said, 'nobody has ever shown me this before.' That is your job. That is the conversation that makes you irreplaceable.

What To Do When They Still Want To Wait

Some buyers will still want to wait. And that is okay. What is not okay is letting them walk out of your office without a plan. If they are going to wait eight months, build an eight-month plan with them right now. What neighborhoods do they want to monitor. What price points. What do they want their first alert to look like. Set up the searches. Schedule a 30-day check-in call. Put it on the calendar before they leave.

Because here is what happens to the buyer who leaves without a plan - they go home, life gets busy, eight months turns into fourteen months, they lose momentum, and they buy from whatever agent happens to reach them when they finally feel ready again. That agent did not earn the relationship. They just showed up at the right time. You showed up at the right time too - the difference is you did the work while everyone else was waiting for them to be ready.

The buyers who say they are not ready are not lost leads. They are some of the best clients you will ever work with - because they are thinking carefully, they want to make a good decision, and they will trust completely the agent who takes them seriously enough to do the real math instead of rushing them toward a commission check.

Want coaching like this every day?

Get matched with your AI coach - free for 14 days.

Start free trial