It happens on almost every transaction that has an inspection. The buyer's agent sends over a repair request that looks like a college textbook, your seller reads it, goes quiet for about thirty seconds, and then says the five words that feel like a solution but almost never are: 'Let's just give them a credit.'
And you smile. Because on the surface, it sounds clean. Nobody has to schedule a contractor. Nobody has to argue about whether the HVAC guy charged too much. The buyer gets money, the seller avoids the hassle, everybody moves forward. Simple, right?
Not even close.
Why a Credit Is Not Always the Easy Way Out
Here is what your seller does not understand yet - and what you have to explain before they dig in and make it a demand. A credit has to actually work inside the deal. If your buyer is financing the purchase, that credit has to fit inside what the lender will allow. Some loan types have hard caps on seller concessions. FHA has limits. Conventional has limits depending on down payment. VA has its own rules. And if the credit your seller wants to give is bigger than what the lender allows, that number gets cut - and nobody is happy when it happens at the closing table.
But it goes deeper than the lending math. A credit does not fix the problem. It transfers the responsibility. And when the buyer moves in and that roof starts leaking six months later, guess who they blame? Not the contractor who never showed up. Not the inspector who flagged it. They blame the transaction. They blame you. And if your seller gave a credit that the buyer never actually used for the repair, that goodwill evaporates fast when the ceiling stains show up.
When a Credit Actually Makes Sense
I am not telling you credits are bad. Sometimes a credit is exactly the right move. If the repair is cosmetic - paint, carpet, something the buyer wants to choose themselves - a credit makes all the sense in the world. If the contractor bids are going to come in all over the place and the buyer has a specific vendor they prefer, a credit streamlines everything. If you are inside a tight closing window and there is no time to schedule and complete the work, a credit keeps the deal alive.
The problem is not credits. The problem is defaulting to credits as the universal answer to every inspection item without thinking through whether it actually solves the specific issue on the table. Your job is to look at what is being asked for, understand what the lender will allow, assess whether this is a repair that needs to be done or a preference the buyer has, and then lead your seller to the right answer - not just the fast answer.
How To Have This Conversation With Your Seller
When your seller says 'just give them a credit,' here is how I want you to respond. Do not nod and go write the addendum. Do not let them feel like they solved it before you have checked the math. Say something like this: 'That may absolutely be the right move - let me check two things first so we do not run into a problem at the closing table.'
Then you check the loan type and the concession cap. You call the lender if you need to - most good lenders will give you a quick answer in five minutes. You look at the specific items being requested and sort them into two buckets: things that are genuinely elective versus things that are structural or systems-related. And then you come back to your seller with a recommendation that is actually grounded in what will close the deal, not just what sounds easy in the moment.
If the credit works inside the loan, great - structure it correctly and move forward. If it does not, your seller needs to know before they get attached to that strategy. That is not a problem. That is you doing your job.
The Agent Who Controls This Conversation Controls the Deal
Inspection negotiations are where a lot of agents go passive. The requests come in, they forward them to the seller, the seller reacts emotionally, and suddenly the agent is just a messenger watching both sides dig into positions. That is not leading. That is following - and following from behind a keyboard.
The agents who close transactions cleanly are the ones who frame the inspection conversation before it starts. They set expectations at the listing appointment about what typically gets requested. They explain upfront that credits have limits depending on the loan. They teach their sellers what a reasonable response looks like so that when the request comes in, the seller is not making a panicked decision - they are executing a strategy they already understood.
Your seller does not know what a lender concession cap is. That is not a criticism. It is a gap you fill. Your buyer's agent does not know whether your seller has already priced in condition. That is information you can use. The inspection negotiation is not a problem that falls in your lap. It is a stage of the transaction where a prepared agent creates separation from everybody else.
Get in front of this conversation before your seller tries to solve it themselves. Because 'just give them a credit' is only the right answer after you have asked the right questions first.
If you want to work through exactly how to handle the inspection conversation from listing appointment to addendum - and stop letting it be the stage where your deals get soft - come find me inside the coaching community. This is exactly the kind of conversation we dig into every week.